Low Friction Creates Inflammation

Friction feels like a dirty word today.

It’s seen as a bug. Efficiency is simultaneously seen as the feature. If only we can remove all friction and get 100% efficiency, we will end up in a utopia!

The problem with this idea is that evolution involves meaningful feedback loops, and friction is a key part of that feedback loop. Friction is feedback. When a tool or technology is so efficient that it brings the friction (or cost) of an action effectively to zero, our biological feedback mechanisms can fail to serve us as they were designed to.

Frictionless Food

The metabolic cost of obtaining calories once regulated consumption. When food acquisition required physical effort, seasonal availability, and energy expenditure, our consumption naturally aligned with our physiological needs. Now that friction is removed, we have but to look at the latest obesity stats to see the challenges that have come from friction-less food. 

With the reduction of friction in agriculture production (including subsidies), we've put corn and its corn-syrup derivation in nearly everything we eat.Whereas it used to cost us an hour of movement foraging and climbing over thorns to collect a handful of seasonal raspberries, we can now down 53 grams of liquified sugar with the twist of a cap. I counted, in my own hands, the raspberry ratio—and a conservative estimate is about 1.5% of the relative effort. This is less than a credit card's transaction worth of friction between us and an early grave.

Frictionless Communication

It once took meaningful friction to send a hand-written letter through our mail system. Email killed the friction. You can now contact anyone and receive messages immediately. Any remaining friction left alive, the messaging apps took it out back and sunk more bullets into it.

Whereas in email there was a social rule that it may take 24h to receive a reply, the messaging apps are 24-7, and global across multiple time zones. We’ve all experienced the feeling of rushing to get to inbox zero, only to realise we’ve just created more future replies for ourselves – like cutting of Hydra’s head, a new one appears. Research from UC Irvine shows that office workers check email every 6 minutes on average, and it takes 23 minutes to fully refocus after each interruption. In the inbox, all inbound is processed nearly equally. Our brain has a hard time distinguishing between the one email we should spend a few hours on and ignoring the rest – with the dopamine desire to get to inbox zero.

It’s never been easier  to contact anyone - however, has this lack of friction improved the quality of our communication, or has it created a more pro-inflammatory workplace?

Frictionless Money

Thought experiment: Imagine deciding between two hotel rooms for a night—one "costs" you the manual labor of moving 250 bricks to earn your stay, the other 500. The choice is clear between the relative effort and value of the hotel room. However, when we abstract labor to dollars, our feedback system changes. It's not all for the worse— it's delightful that I don't need to move bricks every night before bed. But when efficiency brings the relative cost of something close to zero—or we separate the effort of earning money from spending it—we add a layer of abstraction that removes us from biological contact with the relationship of effort to money.

The cost of money (borrowing it) has basically been zero for the last 15 years, which, combined with layers of financial leverage, has allowed for massive distortion in the business world. Consider this example: I own 1 share of Apple Stock, valued at $175. This stock trades on a multiple of 26x net income, meaning the represented value of the stock is priced at 26 times each dollar of actual profits the company generates in the year. In my portfolio, I can borrow against my Apple stock at about a 70% loan-to-value ratio. I can then invest in a fund-of-funds hedge fund. That fund can grab 2-4x leverage from a bank by investing in relatively low volatile assets. Among those investments might include a hedge fund that buys high quality corporate bonds. That fund can get up to 10x leverage on a portfolio of Apple's corporate bonds—bonds underwritten against that same net income I initially bought the value of the stock against!

This means that $1 of net income (actual productive value created by Apple in a year) × 26 (earnings multiple) × 1.7 (individual leverage) × 3 (fund of funds leverage) × 10 (corporate bond fund leverage) = $1,326. That's 1,326 dollars of financial market money for every one dollar of tangible annual production. (This says nothing of the derivative and insurance products that are also created off of that same $1.)

Many businesses, and therefore people, dedicate their whole career around the $1,326 of "value" created by low-friction leverage rather than the $1 portion of tangible goods or services produced. Sounds like a recipe for a few sick days in the market.

The solution isn't to reject technology or return to inefficiency. The frictionless world of mass abundance is better than the friction filled world most of our ancestors struggled and starved through. Each of these improvements in efficiency have created better systems. But with the removal of friction, it has raised the inflammation in the system - from food, to communications, to money.

We may benefit by consciously designing friction back into the systems where it serves our biology - at least until we can evolve to process things differently. To understand that some friction isn’t always a bug – it can be a feature when it comes to biological feedback.

How to improve useful friction inside a business

Some useful bits of friction I’ve found useful:

  1. Writing first culture - Instead of a brainstorming zoom session, write a proposal and outline of what you’re trying to accomplish first.

  2. Holding tanks - A document for non-urgent ideas to run through during the next meeting, rather than firing it off as a Slack message when the idea pops into your head ? 

  3. Friction with customer product send requests (human over typeform)

Where do you think you can add friction to your business to help you?