Be Emotional In Your Decision Making
Emotions offer real signals that guide wiser choices than logic operating alone can.
In 1848, Phineas Gage, a railroad construction foreman in Vermont, was using a tamping iron to pack explosive powder into a rock. An explosion happened. The 3.5-foot iron rod blasted through his left cheek, passed behind his left eye, went through the left frontal lobe of his brain and excited through the top of his skull.
Miraculously, Phineas survived.
In fact, he walked and talked almost immediately after the accident. His memory, motor function, and speech remained intact. However, the regions of his brain tied to emotion, particularly his ventromedial prefrontal cortex was permanently damaged.
Phineas in theory was free to make emotionless decisions. The ultra-rationalist’s dream with no emotion to get in the way of his logical decision making.
The actual result was that Phineas lost his emotional center, and with it, his ability to make basic decisions. ‘
____
His friends could no longer relate to him, and he couldn’t hold down his old job. The neuroscientist Antonio Damasio later built on this, showing patients with frontal lobe damage who could describe choices rationally but became paralyzed by indecision because they felt nothing.
With all historical tales, it’s impossible to get the exact story of what happened – but the story hints at a biological reality that is neglected in most business discourse: Emotions can help decision making, not ruin it. In fact, Harvard published a paper in 2014 reviewing 35 years of work on emotion and decision-making, concluding that the connection is nothing short of a “revolution in science.”
Decision making is not purely rational. Humans need emotional processing to weigh outcomes, make tradeoffs, and act.
If this feels like a newer idea to you, it is. There weren't more than 10 papers per year on emotions and decision making published until 1998. 10 years later in 2008, there are more than 350 published each year.

Your emotional center is what makes decisions. The distinction isn't between emotional and rational decision-making. It's between listening to the full emotional spectrum versus reacting rashly to one emotion or completely shutting down all emotion. The goal is emotional regulation in decision-making, not emotional elimination.

Casually ignoring my emotions for another day of rational emotionless decision making.
Tell me what you feel > Tell me what you think
When people ask for feedback on a marketing campaign or new branding, the question often asked is: “Tell me what you think about this?”. This can lead to a load of post-hoc logical rationalisations.
An alternative question is: “Tell me what you feel about this?”. Just by changing the language from think to feel, it gives them permission to be more emotional with the feedback:
“This feels so fake and plastic.”
“This gives me butterflies in my stomach.”
“This makes me numb.”
By shifting this question we ask our colleagues, it taps into the wisdom of our emotions. The initial gut reaction contains information the analysis can’t provide, and it’s how consumers make a large % of their decisions.
When giving feedback on branding elements, flavors, or campaign ideas, I'm most interested in immediate visceral responses. What does your body tell you before your mind starts constructing explanations? That initial signal—attraction, repulsion, excitement, unease—contains data about how the market will respond because we're all running on similar biological hardware.
Trust the body's wisdom.
Don’t ignore the alarms on the control panel.

Confusion, anger, aversion, or rumination are all markers to pay attention to – not ignore. Don’t turn off what your visceral body is telling you just because you are in a professional context.

